Your Best Teacher Is Not Necessarily Your Next Principal


Published: | by Erin Martin

Share


A principal vacancy opens, and a few familiar names tend to surface quickly: the teacher with consistently strong instruction, the veteran colleagues trust, or the person who takes on extra responsibilities and can always be counted on to follow through.

One of them may be your next great principal. But classroom success gives you only part of the picture. Principalship asks educators to influence adults, navigate conflict, make decisions without having every piece of information, hold people accountable, and maintain trust when others disagree with the decision.

For superintendents and assistant superintendents, that makes principal development more than a succession-planning exercise. The question is how your district can give promising educators opportunities to practice school leadership before asking them to take responsibility for an entire building.

shaping-education-newsletter-ad

What Gets a Teacher Noticed — and What It Doesn’t Tell You

Strong teaching should matter when districts consider future school leaders. Principals need instructional credibility and a clear understanding of what effective teaching looks like. Classroom performance alone, however, cannot show how someone will respond when their success depends on changing another adult’s practice.

Strong Instruction

A teacher may be exceptional at diagnosing what a student needs and adjusting instruction accordingly. As a principal, that same educator may need to tell an experienced teacher their instruction needs to change, explain why, help them improve, and continue working with them the next morning.

Instructional expertise gives future principals an important foundation. But improving instruction across a school requires a different kind of leadership: giving feedback, coaching people with different levels of experience, setting expectations, and helping other adults improve their own practice.

Staff Popularity

Being respected and well-liked can make a teacher an obvious person to consider for leadership. Strong relationships matter, especially when a principal needs staff members to buy into a change or work toward a shared goal.

Those relationships will eventually be tested. Principals have to say no, make unpopular decisions, address performance concerns, and sometimes supervise people who were once peers. The stronger signal is not simply whether colleagues like the person, but whether they continue to trust that person when the conversation gets difficult.

Seniority

Years in the classroom bring experience, judgment, and knowledge of a school community. Those strengths can make an experienced educator an important leader without automatically making principal their best next role.

Some educators may have more impact as mentors, instructional coaches, department leaders, or expert classroom teachers. Districts need room for those paths, too, rather than treating principalship as the expected next step for every accomplished teacher.

Reliability

Every school has educators who become known as the people who can handle almost anything. They organize the event, fix the problem, volunteer for the committee, and step in when something falls through.

That willingness to take responsibility is valuable. But principals cannot succeed by personally absorbing every problem. They have to prioritize, delegate, develop other people, and know when stepping in would keep someone else from growing.

Leadership Readiness Develops Over Time

Christopher Scott did not begin his career planning to become a school administrator. The Moreland University alumnus started as a physical education teacher and remembers being happy working directly with students.

“I didn’t want to lead — ever,” Scott said. “I literally just wanted to be in my zone, working with kids, working within PE [and] sport.”

His responsibilities expanded over time. Scott moved from physical education teacher to head of PE and athletic director before accepting a formal leadership position at an international school in China. As his influence expanded across the school, he realized he needed a broader set of skills, including “leading people, leading learning, leading change, communications.”

That realization eventually led him to pursue Moreland University’s Master’s in Educational Leadership while serving as an assistant principal in Cambodia. He later became head of secondary at an international school in the United Arab Emirates.

Scott’s path is useful for district leaders because there was no single point when success as a teacher proved he was ready to lead a school. He took on broader responsibilities, identified where he needed to grow, developed those skills, and continued taking on more complex roles.

For superintendents building a principal pipeline, that progression matters. Potential leaders need opportunities to test and develop their skills before the district has a vacancy to fill.

pulse-partner-ad_1

Getting the Promotion Wrong Can Cost You Twice

When a district moves a highly effective teacher into a role that does not fit, it risks losing strength in two places. The classroom gives up a proven educator, while the school may gain a leader who is struggling with work that draws on a different set of skills.

A principal’s performance does not stay contained in the principal’s office. School leaders shape instructional priorities, teacher development, school climate, personnel decisions, and educators’ day-to-day working conditions. Research has also linked principal effectiveness and stability with teacher retention and student outcomes.

The answer is not to become hesitant about promoting teachers. Excellent principals often begin as excellent teachers, and classroom experience can provide a valuable foundation. The better question is whether your district has seen enough of how a candidate leads adults before asking that person to lead an entire school.

See Them Lead Before You Promote Them

No interview process, leadership assessment, or succession plan can tell you with certainty who will become an effective principal. Districts can, however, create more opportunities to observe the kinds of leadership the job actually requires.

Before promotion, give aspiring leaders responsibility for a real school or district challenge that cannot be solved by working alone. Then pay attention to how they lead the people involved.

A superintendent or assistant superintendent might ask a prospective leader to:

  • Lead an instructional initiative that requires colleagues to change an established practice.
  • Chair a team whose members have competing priorities and still need to reach a decision.
  • Coach or mentor colleagues and give feedback that is both direct and useful.
  • Develop a recommendation on a real school problem, gather input, make a call, and explain the tradeoffs behind it.
  • Debrief afterward with an experienced leader about how they handled resistance, delegation, communication, and difficult decisions.

The assignment should be real enough to reveal how someone leads but structured enough to limit risk. Treat it as development, not a hidden audition in which every misstep counts against the person.

The outcome does not always need to be a future principal. An educator may discover that instructional leadership is a better fit than personnel management. Someone else may reveal a strength for handling conflict, while another may need more time and coaching. Those are useful outcomes for both the district and the educator.

Build the Pipeline Before You Have a Vacancy

For superintendents, a stronger principal pipeline starts before someone applies. Look at who is being given responsibility beyond their own classroom and who has had to lead peers through disagreement or change.

Then give those educators more chances to do the work. Watch how they build trust when a conversation gets uncomfortable, make decisions when every option has a downside, and get other people moving without simply taking the work back themselves.

Research on principal pipelines supports that broader approach. In six large districts studied as part of The Wallace Foundation’s Principal Pipeline Initiative, districts built principal pipelines around stronger preparation, selective hiring and placement, and on-the-job evaluation and support.

You still will not know with certainty who will become a great principal. But you will know considerably more than you can learn from years of service, classroom reputation, or a strong interview alone.

Help Aspiring Leaders Prepare for What Comes Next

For educators who decide school leadership is the right next step, formal preparation can add another layer of experience. Moreland University’s 100% online Master’s in Educational Leadership can be completed in as little as 12 months and includes coursework in areas such as instructional leadership, school operations, strategic planning, budgeting, and data-informed decision-making, along with a hands-on leadership internship.

For districts, that preparation can complement the work already happening internally: Identify educators with leadership potential, give them meaningful opportunities to lead adults, provide coaching, and make promotion decisions based on more than the qualities that first got them noticed.

district-partner-ad_2

Interested in developing more school leaders from within your district? Learn more about Moreland University’s Master’s in Educational Leadership program and district partnership opportunities.

Additional Reading