Empowering Educators | Why Teachers Need Autonomy in 2025

Teacher satisfaction is low. Only 33% of U.S. teachers are extremely satisfied with their job, according to a recent Pew Research Center survey, and a chunk of that discontent comes from a lack of autonomy.

An article from Education Week says teachers “often feel micromanaged and left out of decision-making rooms.” They report having the least control over their schedule, school policies, the resources and supplies they need, and the curriculum they teach.

Increasing teacher autonomy won’t solve every issue plaguing schools. But it will help increase teacher satisfaction, which in turn leads to better teacher performance and improved retention.

“Teachers need to feel appreciated and respected,” said Moreland University graduate and international educator Chandini Ganju. “…Just as we try to give our students a choice and a voice, teachers also deserve the same.”

Why Teacher Autonomy Matters

Here’s why teacher autonomy matters, and why you, as a school leader, should prioritize a culture of autonomy in 2025:

#1 Innovation

Autonomy empowers teachers to experiment with new teaching methods, such as gamification or incorporating new technologies into the classroom. If every teacher is doing the exact same thing, there are no new ideas and no growth.

#2 Adaptability

The rapid evolution of education requires flexibility and creativity. Teachers with more autonomy are better positioned to adapt to changes and find new and more effective ways to run their classrooms.

#3 Teacher Satisfaction and Retention

Autonomy reduces burnout and empowers teachers to grow their skills and careers.

“Essentially,” said Moreland graduate and Iowa educator Cole Cooper, “the more autonomy a teacher has, the more likely they are to remain employed at a school.”

As much as possible, let your teachers lead. Give them freedom in how they plan lessons, run their classrooms, and structure work with their teacher teams.

#4 Student Outcomes

As autonomy builds teacher retention, students benefit from stable instruction with less turnover year-to-year. Teachers with autonomy are in a better position to respond to students’ individual needs and to empower students to succeed.

“They can scaffold in a more free manner,” said Gangu, the Moreland grad, “and change instruction as required during their classes.”

How to Empower Autonomy

So, what can you do? How can you foster autonomy in your school, district, or organization? Step 1 is simple: Ask your teachers. Where would they like more flexibility or freedom? What changes would they like to make or see?

From there, here are 4 more autonomy boosting ideas:

#1 Teacher-Led Professional Development

Ask your teachers what they’re interested in learning or what skills they’d like to develop, and base your professional development on their answers. If you have a teacher who is particularly interested in artificial intelligence, for example, you could send her to a conference on incorporating AI into the classroom. Afterward, she could present what she learns to the rest of your teaching staff.

You could also try offering a small stipend to teachers who want to create and run their own professional development sessions, based on their particular skills and interests.

Professional development should be more than just checking a box. It should be enriching and interesting for your teachers, based on what they want to learn and how they want to grow.

#2 No Micromanagement

This one is simple. Make sure school policies and procedures are clear, then trust your teachers to do their jobs.

Micromanaging can be hugely detrimental to teacher morale, not to mention, if you’re micromanaging as a school leader, it takes up a ton of your time as well. When you step back and trust your teachers as professionals, everyone wins.

#3 Flexible School Policies

Inject flexibility into your rules whenever it makes sense. This could mean giving teachers freedom in how they implement curriculum. As long as they’re meeting state standards, let them experiment with different teaching styles and methods. Let them collaborate to share ideas, best practices, and even specific lesson plans.

Or perhaps you could create a more flexible schedule (as long as your teachers are available during instruction hours) or a more flexible dress code. The idea is to give your teachers freedom to express their personalities and fine-tune their teaching habits to what works best for them.

#4 Open Communication

This is crucial to teacher autonomy. Teachers have to know they can come to you with questions, concerns, or any other feedback, good or bad. You are there to support them, and they should always feel comfortable speaking up.

The Future of Teacher Autonomy

With new technologies and the increasing globalization of education, the importance of teacher autonomy will only grow in the coming years. Think about artificial intelligence, personalized learning, and project-based teaching.

Without teacher autonomy, these might sound like problems to solve. How do you stop students from using AI? How do you standardize curriculum and teach to the test?

But with teacher autonomy, these can instead be opportunities. Teachers can find new and exciting ways to share knowledge and reach their students. They can grow professionally and enhance their careers, leading to happier, more invested educators, and better results for students and schools.

---

Want more resources for school leaders? Join our monthly Shaping Education newsletter community for actionable ideas, inspiring stories, and helpful resources to share with your staff.